Mobile deathmatch: Windows Phone 7 vs. Apple iPhone 4

Microsoft has a very slick device, but it can't do nearly as much as the iPhone - especially in business

Deathmatch: ApplicationsThe iPhone provides more useful apps than Windows Phone 7 does. Both provide email, contacts, calendar, browser, calculator (except on the iPad), maps, a music player, photo display, a video player, multi-user gaming, and SMS messaging apps. The apps are equivalent in most cases. One exception is the photos app, where the iPhone supports albums and Windows Phone 7 does not. Another exception is the maps app, where the iPhone provides satellite views in addition to cartographic ones; the iPhone's maps app is also much faster at returning directions.

The iPhone provides several apps that Windows Phone 7 does not, including those for a clock, the weather (except on the iPad), stocks, voice memo, and YouTube. Although Windows Phone 7 supports alarms, it offers only a subset of what the iPhone's clock app does.

Windows Phone 7 has a set of apps called Office: Word, Excel, and OneNote. But don't let the Office name fool you -- Word and OneNote are very rudimentary apps, good for basic notes entry and extremely light editing. For example, tap and hold a word to select it; from there, you can make it bold, apply a colored highlight to it, or add a note -- but you can't select a range of text. You can't choose fonts either, though you can apply numbered and bulleted lists.

Excel likewise is good only for very basic editing; constructing formulas is very difficult, as you can't tap a cell to enter it into a formula. You can tap the fx icon to get a list of formulas, as in the desktop version, but the default keyboard for Excel doesn't display two of the most common symbols used in formulas: = and *; you have to switch to a second symbols keyboard.

Ironically, Windows Phone 7 lets you access SharePoint servers to open documents stored there -- yet any organization that uses SharePoint is certain to require security policies for corporate access that Windows Phone 7 does not support. Document access via cloud services such as Box.net and Dropbox are not supported.

The iPhone comes with a basic note-taking app. It uses a hard-to-read font but is otherwise easy to work with for simple documents (no formatting allowed). If you want Office-like functionality, you'll need to buy an app such as the $15 Quickoffice or $17 Documents to Go. Both are far superior to Windows Phone 7's Office apps when working with Office documents, so keep your fingers crossed for Windows Phone 7 editions.

App stores and app installation. Windows Phone 7 is too new to have much in the way of third-party apps available in the Windows Phone Marketplace, and most of the current stock is basic or forgettable - I haven't seen attractive apps yet. Apple's App Store also suffers from having lots of junkware, which comes with the territory of 99-cent apps, and it took some time for really useful apps to become available.

As a store, the Windows Phone Marketplace is poorly designed. You can choose from a bunch of categories and search within a store, but there's no way to sort through the long list of options. By contrast, Apple's App Store lets you view and sort categories much more easily.

Installation of apps is similar: After selecting an app, you confirm your store account information and wait for the app to download and install.

Both Windows Phone Marketplace and App Store reside on the home screen and alert you to when updates are available.

App management. The iPhone has a simple app management process. For example, it's easy to arrange your home screens to cluster applications both on your iPhone and on your desktop via iTunes; you can also put them in your own folders. Just tap and hold any app to invoke the "shaking apps" status, in which you can drag apps wherever you want or tap the X icon to delete them (press the Home button when done to exit that mode). You can also arrange and delete apps using iTunes on your desktop.

Windows Phone 7 lets you pin apps to the home screen, creating a tile for each app there. You can then rearrange tiles by dragging them to a desired location on the app screen or delete them by tapping the X icon. All apps are available in an alphabetical list if you slide to the right of the home screen. You can't rearrange the list or create folders, though.

The iPhone has long let you add Web pages to home screens as if they were apps. That's great for the many mobile Web pages such as iphone.infoworld.com that are essentially Web apps. Windows Phone 7 has a similar capability.

Both the iPhone and Windows Phone 7 let you manage apps on your desktop using their iTunes and Zune clients, respectively. Microsoft has a beta sync client for Macs that works reasonably well for transferring video, music, photos, and podcasts to the phone -- but it doesn't let you manage apps.

Multitasking. iOS 4 brought multitasking, in a limited way, to iPhones this summer, providing APIs that let apps enable multitasking for specific functions, as well as a mechanism to switch among and close running apps. iPhone apps must be enabled by the developer to use the limited set of multitasking capabilities iOS 4 provides.

Windows Phone 7 doesn't support multitasking at all.

The winner: The iPhone, thanks to a selection of apps and strong app quality that far outshine what's available for Windows Phone 7. Plus, the absence of multitasking is a serious omission in Windows Phone 7.

Deathmatch: Web and InternetIn the desktop world, Microsoft is behind everyone else in its support for HTML5. The same is true in mobile, where it alone does not support the common draft specifications for HTML5.

For regular HTML4 pages, Windows Phone 7's IE7-based browser works well, displaying pages with good detail, and allowing panning and zooming with the same gestures that the iPhone has popularized. The Web viewing experience -- both quality and rendering speed -- of Windows Phone 7 is similar to that of the iPhone, though zooming is not as smooth.

On some mobile-formatted pages, such as iphone.infoworld.com, Windows Phone 7 had trouble displaying the contents, while on others (such as m.yahoo.com) it did not. The pages Windows Phone 7 had problems with render perfectly fine in iOS, BlackBerry OS, webOS, and Android.

Because Windows Phone 7 supports neither copy and paste nor multitasking, you cannot select text or graphics and copy them elsewhere, such as in emails. You can share the URLs of Web pages via email or SMS. The iPhone supports copy and paste, as well as URL sharing.

Both OSes lets you open multiple Web pages, but you can view just one at a time. Windows Phone 7 uses one field for searches and URL entries, whereas the iPhone has one field for each. I think both approaches work just fine.

The two OSes let you bookmark Web pages and add Web pages to your home screen (called "pinning" in Windows Phone 7), but only the iPhone lets you place them in bookmark folders. Bookmarks are one big list in Windows Phone 7.

Neither device supports Adobe Flash. Microsoft has suggested it will do so in the future. Apple of course has no plans to allow Flash support, given Apple's dislike of the Adobe Flash technology.

In a misguided effort to promote other Microsoft products, Windows Phone 7 provides only the Bing search engine, whose results are not always great. The iPhone lets you choose among Google, Yahoo, and Bing. (Google has made a Google Search app available in the Windows Phone Marketplace.)

But a nice capability in Windows Phone 7 is its ability to report itself to websites as a desktop browser, for those times you don't want the site's mobile-optimized pages, through a simple settings control for Internet Explorer. I wish the iPhone could do that to avoid some of the horrible mobile sites out there.

I also like the voice-recognition capability in Bing. It's pleasantly accurate in letting you search the Web via voice -- even more accurate than Android's similar feature. The iPhone can't search via voice recognition. 

The winner: The iPhone, thanks to its support of HTML5, broad search engine support, and ability to copy text and graphics.

Deathmatch: Location supportBoth the iPhone and Windows Phone 7 support GPS location, and both can triangulate location based on Wi-Fi signals. As noted earlier, the iPhone's maps app is better than Windows Phone 7's, though both are serviceable.

Although both the iPhone and Windows Phone 7 ask for permission to use your location information, Windows Phone 7 does not provide controllable settings for location use by the device or individual applications, as the iPhone does. (Windows Phone 7 does let you enable location detection to influence its search results, but that's not about helping you manage your privacy, as the iPhone's capability is.)

The winner: The iPhone, for its better maps app and its ability to control location privacy at a granular level.

Tags Mobile platformstelecommunicationioswindows phone 7PhonesiPhonesmartphonesMobilizemobileAppleconsumer electronicsMicrosoft

Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

4 Comments

Jodi

1

I see an article by Galen Gruman and the word iPhone or Apple in it and I don't bother reading. I think the iPhone is great, but it would be nice to have some honest reviews of other platforms instead of hundreds of slanted apple fanboy articles.

Joe Z.

2

I know, Galen Gruman isn't exactly a reliable review. Here are just a couple of errors he made. These are just the factual errors, not the biased statements. Some of these features he's wrong on have been covered correctly by other reviewers for MONTHS. Some are really glaring.

1. MESSAGE SELECTION. All you have to do is tap to the left on a message you want to select. To select additional messages, tap the boxes that have now appeared.

2, 3. INBOX FOLDERS. Once you've told Windows Phone to sync a folder, it'll always appear in the "all folders" list. No "extra tap" on "show all folders" needed. And Windows Phone DOES let you set which folders to sync or not.

4. Downloading attachments is just a tap, not a tap-and-hold. Same with opening them... a small one, but, these are big:

5, 6. Calendar invites DO get sent immediately. And yes, Windows Phone 7 places meeting requests right on your calendar, and you can respond to them.

7. The IS a quick-jump function in contacts. Just click on one of the blue heading letters for the jump list.

8. He conveniently omits that the Photos app syncs all you cloud albums including Facebook as if they are on the phone.

9. Bing Maps DOES HAVE SATTELITE VIEW. Duh. AND it comes in automatically if you zoom.

10. This is getting boring. He dings Windows Phone for not including weather, stocks apps, but they're Microsoft apps available free from the Marketplace.

11. Contrarywise, he dings Windows Phone for INCLUDING Office apps (iPhone doesn't) because they are not full-features editors.

12. He implies that Inwodws Phone doesn't come with a note-taking app, but it comes with OneNote, which syncs automatically to your skydrive and your desktop.

13. Yes, you can sort through the list of Marketplace apps by category and subcategory, and by top, free, and new.

14. Omits Live Tile notification.

15. Windows Phone 7 supports multitasking of native apps.

16. Zooming is super-smooth in Windows Phone 7 IE, say most other reviewers.

17. Complains that InfoWorld's IPHONE-designed web page doesn't render properly. (Infoworld connection, there.) Also, the page was designed for iPhone, hello.

18. You CAN save graphics from the web however, and then insert them into an email message.

19. You can search Google from Windows Phone 7 with the Google App! Just like the Bing app on iPhone.

20... I'm too bored to go on, and too bored to keep reading the article. I never imagined I'd be making a list this long!

j

3

I was going to state the same things.. but there are so many things that are wrong with the artical is much to much effort.

Lets just say a majaority of this article is wrong and/or selectivley missing things to allow the writer to state half truths.

This is like a list of things the BETA didnt have many months ago.

Anonymous

4

All people are just iPhone fans. The iPhone wasn't the most popular phone when it came out. This post is wrong the WP7 can do so much more then the iPhone. In the contats there is a quick jump. One WP7 has a 1.8ghz processer while the iPhone only has 800Mhz. People are just on the Apple side, give the WP7 and Microsft a chance!

Comments are now closed.

Most Popular Reviews

Follow Us

Best Deals on GoodGearGuide

Shopping.com

Latest News Articles

Resources

GGG Evaluation Team

Kathy Cassidy

STYLISTIC Q702

First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.

Anthony Grifoni

STYLISTIC Q572

For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.

Steph Mundell

LIFEBOOK UH574

The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.

Andrew Mitsi

STYLISTIC Q702

The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.

Simon Harriott

STYLISTIC Q702

My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.

Latest Jobs

Shopping.com

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?