Bertelsmann forms alliance with Napster
- — 01 November, 2000 10:53
Bertelsmann AG's newly formed eCommerce Group, BeCG, and Napster have developed a membership-based service that will provide file-sharing capabilities that "preserves the Napster experience while at the same time providing payments to the rightsholders," the company said in a statement. Napster and Bertelsmann will seek support from others in the music industry to accept Napster as a membership-based service, the companies said.
Once Napster implements the service, BMG will withdraw its lawsuit against Napster and make its music catalogue available. Bertelsmann will provide Napster a loan to develop the new service. Bertelsmann spokeswoman Christiane Hach in Germany said details of the loan were not being disclosed.
Details on how the actual membership-based file sharing arrangement would work also were thin.
"The details of how this will (work) haven't been disclosed," Hach said. "To really go into details on the business model ... it would be too early."
In a statement, Napster chief executive officer Hank Barry said the alliance is the "right step" for Napster and the Napster community would benefit from the alliance with Bertelsmann.
The Recording Industry Association of America filed suit against Napster on behalf of the five major record labels, including BMG, earlier this year alleging copyright infringement and asked for damages and an immediate stoppage of the peer-to-peer file sharing service.
This alliance and the possibility that BMG could drop out of the RIAA lawsuit will not deter the other music labels from going forward with their legal action against Napster, said Leonard Rubin, head of intellectual property at the US law firm Gordon and Glickson LLC. Rubin, who has represented record companies, musicians and composers, said BMG's move was telling.
"One of the plaintiffs has begun to recognise that Napster has something to sell with over 30 million (users)," Rubin said.
The next logical question is whether the other four recording labels will also seek to make friends with Napster. The RIAA did not returned repeated calls Tuesday, but did release a statement about Bertelsman's announcement.
Hilary Rosen, the RIAA's president and chief executive officer, said in the statement that Napster's move makes it clear that it is "better to work with the creative community than against it." But she said the announcement does not end the lawsuit and that the ground rules of the Internet music business should "be established once and for all."
Rosen said the case has always been about sending a message to the technology and venture capital communities that consumers, creators and innovators will flourish when copyright interests are respected. The RIAA's lawsuit against Napster has never been about peer-to-peer technology, she said. She said she was glad that Napster "has gotten the message," and hopes the announcement sends the right signal to others who are operating or intend to operate sites that facilitate piracy.