LA Noire review: Approach this game as an interactive movie, not as an open world
- Facial expressions on characters are extremely convincing
- Excellent storyline and script
- Cutscenes leave you wanting more
- Lack of freedom
- Evidence gathering and action sequences can sometimes be a bit bland
LA Noire is a groundbreaking game with a gripping story and beautiful presentation that should be appreciated more as an interactive movie than an open world game.
Price$ 108.00 (AUD)
It does end up feeling like a point and click game but if players want to turn the difficulty dial up, they can always turn off the music and vibration cues in the options menu.
There are multiple ways a case can be solved; arriving at a particular location earlier may yield new sets of evidence. But more often than not the cases will conclude in the same manner. If you convict the wrong guy, you cop a verbal beating from your superior and you always have the option of restarting the mission.
The game still has replay value in that you may unlock new clues or cutscenes if you approach a case in an alternative way. Replay value is in trying to get a five star rating for every case by collecting all the available clues, getting all the right answers out of interviewees and causing minimal damage to the city.
LA Noire does try to spice things up with random car chases, some gun fights and pursue-the-fleeing-suspect type activities. But there isn’t much variety and by the end I found these interludes somewhat tedious.
I’ll admit I’m slightly bitter that I was unable to run amok in the street of LA, shooting or running down innocent bystanders because A) I can’t pull a gun out unless a certain mission allows it and B) I am the law enforcement. The damage I cause to public property and civilians will impact my performance in any given case, so there is a huge incentive to be a goody two‐shoes.
But hey, there’s always free‐roaming mode. You can’t use this mode until you have finished up in each crime division, so you will still have to go through the more restrictive main storyline at least once. But if you are craving some carnage, free‐roaming mode allows you to release your inner lunatic on the streets of 1940s LA and replay completed missions. It’s a pity there is no multiplayer component to it.
One important worth highlighting is the ability to be lazy and let your partner do the driving. This is great for saving time; the game will automatically fade out and skip straight to the destination unless there is some important banter between Phelps and his partner. The flipside is you will be less inclined to explore the beautifully crafted city.
There is an incentive to drive to places yourself: There are opportunities to tackle random street crimes, although I didn’t find them every exciting and ended up just anxious to get on with the task at hand.
A note on the whole film noir aspect of the game: Some of the cases in the beginning actually do start off with a very strong “dark cinema” influence through dramatic music with a minimalist flash of the case file name and a black and white fade-in sequence. Players are then given a glimpse at when a particular crime occurred, which leads into Phelps being assigned to investigate and the player taking control.
Halfway through the game, the “noir” theme seems to have been forgotten. LA Noire then transforms into a police drama film dealing with corruption throughout all facets of law and order. The case titles still appear but it doesn’t always jump straight into scenes that reveal how a crime was committed.
I wouldn’t say the story gets worse from that point on; in fact, the game retains a strong and engaging storyline almost up to the very end. Some plot twists are weaved in nice enough although it is hard to comment without giving out spoilers. But the sudden change of path and pace left me a bit dazed and mouthing “WTF?” to myself.
I like murder mysteries and I like police drama (although not as much) but the segue between the two was executed in a clumsy manner. The conclusion to the serial killer saga was too abrupt in my opinion.
Nonetheless, I was sucked into the story by well‐placed flashbacks slowly unravelling Phelp’s dark past and newspapers triggering cutscenes that reveals the back story of a crime central to the plot. For those expecting a detective game with unlimited possibilities and ways to solve crimes, bitter disappointment awaits.
But what LA Noire can offer is a glimpse into the future of gaming. It has set a benchmark for game developers to aim for and to supersede. If LA Noire succeeds as a wonderfully well‐made interactive movie now, just think of what the gaming industry will come up with in the next few years.
Join the PC World newsletter!
Most Popular Reviews
- 1 Kogan Agora 4G Pro review: the final word on Kogan's best smartphone
- 2 Sony Xperia Z4 Tablet (LTE) review: The tablet of choice for anyone on Android
- 3 Bose SoundLink Mini II Bluetooth speaker review
- 4 Apple MacBook Air 2015 review: Only better with time
- 5 Lenovo ThinkPad T550 laptop
Deals on PC World
- Networking, Wireless & VoIP
Deals on PC World
Latest News Articles
- Angry Birds 2 is the 'sequel' you've been waiting for
- Rising Thunder is a PC-exclusive robot brawler built by Street Fighter talent
- Nintendo's President Iwata's death comes as firm tries to move to mobile
- Batman: Arkham Knight (PC) review: Holy squandered potential, Batman
- Batman: Arkham Knight: How bad are the issues? Pretty bad.
GGG Evaluation Team
First impression on unpacking the Q702 test unit was the solid feel and clean, minimalist styling.
For work use, Microsoft Word and Excel programs pre-installed on the device are adequate for preparing short documents.
The Fujitsu LifeBook UH574 allowed for great mobility without being obnoxiously heavy or clunky. Its twelve hours of battery life did not disappoint.
The screen was particularly good. It is bright and visible from most angles, however heat is an issue, particularly around the Windows button on the front, and on the back where the battery housing is located.
My first impression after unboxing the Q702 is that it is a nice looking unit. Styling is somewhat minimalist but very effective. The tablet part, once detached, has a nice weight, and no buttons or switches are located in awkward or intrusive positions.
- FTDevOps Consultant - Microsoft Experience - Digital ConsultancyVIC
- FTDesktop Engineering ManagerNSW
- FTBusiness Development Manager & Account ManagerVIC
- CCMarketing Coordinator - World's largest search engine!NSW
- CCLead Generator - Software SolutionsNSW
- FTSenior Network EngineerNSW
- FTField EngineerNSW
- FTTechnical Sales Support Representative - The Worlds largest Search Engine!NSW
- CCAccount Strategist | Sales Executive | Global Search EngineNSW