Western Digital My Passport Studio 500GB external hard drive

A fast external hard drive with FireWire 800 and an electronic label

PC World Australia (online)

Mac users rejoice: Western Digital has finally upgraded its My Passport external hard drive range with a FireWire 800 interface. This means faster transfers, though the considerably thicker enclosure is a slight trade-off for Nudie-wearing hipsters.

Pros

  • FireWire 800 provides fast transfer speeds, FireWire 400 to 800 adapter provided, hardware encryption

Cons

  • WD SmartWare backup software has limitations, eInk label is largely a gimmick

Bottom Line

Western Digital charges a premium for its flagship Mac-formatted external hard drive, but the addition of an eInk label and the faster FireWire 800 interface make it a worthwhile choice of you need to transfer large files.

Would you buy this?

  • Price

    $ 239.99 (AUD)

Special Offers

The biggest difference between Western Digital's Studio-branded external hard drives and the company's Essential models has traditionally been connectivity. The WD My Passport Studio offers up both USB 2.0 and the speedier FireWire 800, while the Essential models only have the former. As we noted with the My Passport Essential SE, WD is using micro-USB ports, which are allegedly sturdier than starndard USB ports but the cables can be more annoying to replace.

FireWire 800 is a great inclusion if you have a compatible device; it has a theoretical maximum bandwidth of 800 megabits per second. USB 2.0 is restricted to 480Mbps. It's also known to have a higher average throughput when transferring large files, which should mean faster overall performance using the interface. Western Digital even includes a FireWire 800 to 400 adapter, which means you'll be able to use the connection with older Macs and Windows PCs like the HP Pavilion Slimline S5380a.

The downside, though, is that FireWire 800 is a large interface, which means the My Passport Studio is bulkier than it would be otherwise. It's even slightly thicker than the higher capacity My Passport SE, so it might not fit in small pockets so easily.

An unusual feature of the WD My Passport Studio is its electronic label, which is like the one found on the My Book Elite. The eInk display is similar to the screens of e-book readers like the Amazon Kindle, and essentially acts as a capacity gauge and volume label. You can change the label with the bundled Windows and Mac-compatible WD SmartWare software and it can stay visible without power for six months. If you have multiple external hard drives, you can label what each one is used for.

Western Digital doesn’t include any formatting tools, so if you choose to change between Windows and Mac file systems, you’ll have to do it the old-fashioned way. Thankfully, all bundled software is protected on the drive; if you do format, you won’t lose any of the utilities like you would on the Hitachi SimpleDRIVE Mini.

WD SmartWare Label configuration

WD SmartWare lets you change your hard drive's label.

The bundled WD SmartWare software acts as a configuration hub for the hard drive, letting you configure the eInk label and manage the 256-bit AES hardware encryption and backup schedules.

WD SmartWare's backup utility is, like the HP SimpleSave Portable, designed to be intuitive and largely automatic. After categorising data on your computer and the external hard drive based on file extensions, WD SmartWare lets you choose which types of file formats to back up. While certainly simple, it doesn't let users set custom extensions, so obscure formats are simply be listed as "other" and bundled with miscellaneous system files. WD SmartWare supports up to 25 sequential backups of the same file, though the scope of configuration isn't as great as that offered by the BlackArmor WS 110.

Unfortunately, all the extra features do affect the price tag somewhat; with the current RRP you can expect a cost per formatted gigabyte of 51.6c. By contrast, a 500GB external hard drive without all the extra functionality (like the Astone ISO GEAR 290) will cost you about 32c per formatted gigabyte.

Performance

Small File (3GB) Transfer Test Results
Model Price Storage Capacity Interface Read
speed (MBps)		 Write
speed (MBps)		 Read/write
speed (MBps)
Western Digital My Passport Studio $239.99 500GB USB 2.0 25.4 13.1 7.2
FireWire 800 42.8 51.7 86.2
Hitachi SimpleDRIVE Mini $109 320GB USB 2.0 26.1 17.5 11
LaCie Rikiki (USB Boost enabled) $159 500GB USB 2.0 30.9 17.2 11.1
LaCie Starck Mobile Hard Drive $139 320GB USB 2.0 24.5 17.1 11.1
Astone ISO GEAR 290 $149 500GB USB 2.0 20.5 13.5 9.7
HP SimpleSave Portable $139 320GB USB 2.0 20.4 12.6 8.2
Transcend StoreJet 25M-R $159.95 320GB USB 2.0 23.8 15.3 7.2
Western Digital My Passport SE $379 1TB USB 2.0 26.7 11.7 7.6

Large File (20GB) Transfer Test Results
Model Price Storage Capacity Interface Read
speed (MBps)		 Write
speed (MBps)		 Read/write
speed (MBps)
Western Digital My Passport Studio $239.99 500GB USB 2.0 28.1 21.2 9.7
FireWire 800 63.6 58.6 30.5
Hitachi SimpleDRIVE Mini $109 320GB USB 2.0 28.9 23.8 12.7
LaCie Rikiki (USB Boost enabled) $159 500GB USB 2.0 37.7 26.7 13.3
LaCie Starck Mobile Hard Drive $139 320GB USB 2.0 27.4 25.9 12.7
Astone ISO GEAR 290 $149 500GB USB 2.0 28.7 25.2 11.5
HP SimpleSave Portable $139 320GB USB 2.0 27.9 25.1 11.6
Transcend StoreJet 25M-R $159.95 320GB USB 2.0 28.5 24.3 11.9
Western Digital My Passport SE $379 1TB USB 2.0 31.4 24.8 11.2

The My Passport Studio is an average performer when using the USB 2.0 connection, and you can expect similar results when using the FireWire 400 adapter. However, the FireWire 800 interface means you’ll be able to transfer large files at a much faster rate.

While we’re not convinced that an eInk label is useful on a portable hard drive, the FireWire 800 interface is certainly a godsend for Mac users who want to transfer large files regularly. Power users may want to invest in a better backup suite, however.

Stay up to date with the latest news, reviews and features. Sign up to PC World’s newsletters

Follow PC World Australia on Twitter: @PCWorldAu

Read more on these topics: storage,

User Comments

1

AndreiTue 18/01/2011 - 03:53

If you are expecting to use this drive firewire/os x, check the reviews before buying. Major issues there. USB seems to work without problems, only it's very slow (with os x, at least).

Make your own

Comment
Review
This will be kept private.
0.00
Users posting comments agree to the PC World comments policy.

Most Popular

What's the difference between an Intel Core i3, i5 and i7?
How do I connect my TV to the Internet?
Samsung Galaxy S III vs. HTC One X: Head-to-head
Apple iPad 2 vs Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1: Tablet showdown
Laser vs. inkjet printers: which is better?

Best Deals on PCWorld

TabletsView all »
NotebooksView all »
Mobile PhonesView all »
Printers & ScannersView all »
Networking, Wireless & VoIPView all »