The nine most overrated games of 2009

Named & shamed: the nine most overrated video games of 2009

The nine most overrated games of 2009 prev next

Loading...

9. Brutal Legend (PS3, Xbox 360)



Has Tim Schafer ever made a game that wasn't overrated? From The Secret of Monkey Island (which he merely co-wrote) to the deeply uneven Psychonauts, his games seem to garner a lot more praise than they actually deserve. Brutal Legend is no different. Despite openly acknowledging that the gameplay is quite weak, most games journalists awarded the game a score of 80 per cent or more — presumably because Tim Schafer's name was on it. We refuse to believe that they're all heavy metal/Jack Black fans, which is the only way you could love this video game.

Prev Next 2/19

Comments on this image

Close

The nine most overrated games of 2009

19 images
Shopping.com

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?