Leopard's firewall a 'mess,' breaks Skype, says researcher

Former Gartner analyst blasts new Mac OS X firewall, but says it's fixable

Leopard's firewall is confusing, inconsistent, switched off by default and incompatible with some applications, a security researcher said after analyzing the new security tool.

"This firewall is a mess," Rich Mogull, a security consultant and former Gartner analyst, said after spending two days digging into the new firewall's capabilities. "It's a step back from Tiger's firewall. I was originally pretty bullish on Leopard's security, and I still am on the concepts, but the implementation makes most of its advances ineffective or unusable."

The firewall in Mac OS X 10.5, a.k.a Leopard uses a bare-bones interface -- earlier this week, Mogull called it "so simple as to be nearly useless" -- that offers users three options:

  • Allow all incoming connections
  • Block all incoming connections
  • Set access for specific services and applications
Other settings let users switch on the stealth mode, which is supposed to cloak all ports on the Mac, preventing attackers from even "seeing" the machine when scanning the Internet for open ports, and probing for potential victims. After a Leopard upgrade, the firewall is set to the first, "Allow all..." which means, in fact, that the firewall is switched off. Users with machines that had the firewall turned on also saw their firewall turned off after Leopard was installed.

"'Block all...' does seem to block actual connections," said Mogull, "but any shared ports are detected as 'open/filtered' on a port scan." And unless users turn on stealth, some services -- Bonjour, Apple's network device locating technology, is one -- are seen as open by scans, no matter what firewall setting is selected. Only by using "Block all..." with stealth enabled are shared services actually invisible.

"In short, 'Block all...' seems to block inbound connections but ports show as open/filtered," he said. "Stealth mode works, partially, but some ports still show on a port scan no matter what. Bonjour is always accessible, unless you're in stealth mode."

Those inconsistencies pale against the firewall's ability to break some applications without warning. While testing the firewall's "Set access..." option, Mogull discovered that Leopard prevents some applications from running.

When the "Set access...." mode is turned on, Leopard digitally signs applications that the user allows access to incoming communication. But if that application is subsequently changed -- say when it's updated to a new version -- the signature no longer matches and the application won't run. While that's typical of firewalls, Leopard also blocks applications that change at runtime. Skype, the popular VoIP software and instant messenger, is one such program.

If the user has set the firewall to "Set access..." and runs Skype, the icon will bounce a time or two on the dock, but not load. Nor does Leopard tell the user that Skype has failed or why it won't launch. Only the Mac OS X Console gives a clue, with a message such as: 11/2/07 9:47:51 AM [0x0-0x35035].com.skype.skype[399] Check 1 failed. Can't run Skype

"You can fix this by reinstalling Skype," said Mogull, "and it will work until the next time it's run. Then you have to reinstall Skype again. That's a bit of a problem."

Skype has acknowledged the problem as far back as August, but while it said then it was working on a fix, no version compatible with the Leopard firewall has been issued. (The last Mac OS X Skype update was released in July.)

"I was close to recommending the firewall in app signing mode ["Set access..."], but not with this problem of breaking applications," he said. Instead, users should rely on the protection built into their routers. "If you have a wireless router between the modem and your Mac, you're fine," he said.

But even a flawed firewall isn't fatal, Mogull noted, for Mac users. "I run a firewall, but it's kind of out of habit from my days with Windows," he said. "I like that extra layer of protection." But there have been few cases where exploits have actually claimed success against Apple's systems. "There was a zero-day, but that's been patched. I don't know of any ways of getting in today." He declined to name the exploit.

"Fortunately, all of this is fixable," he said. "Apple clearly was a little rushed, but they're moving in the right direction. It's our responsibility to keep on Apple to make sure they convert these concepts into actual implementations."

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

Gregg Keizer

Computerworld
Show Comments

Father’s Day Gift Guide

Brand Post

Bitdefender 2019

Bitdefender solutions stop attacks before they even begin! Get cybersecurity that 500 MILLION users already have and trust.

Most Popular Reviews

Latest Articles

Resources

PCW Evaluation Team

Luke Hill

MSI GT75 TITAN

I need power and lots of it. As a Front End Web developer anything less just won’t cut it which is why the MSI GT75 is an outstanding laptop for me. It’s a sleek and futuristic looking, high quality, beast that has a touch of sci-fi flare about it.

Emily Tyson

MSI GE63 Raider

If you’re looking to invest in your next work horse laptop for work or home use, you can’t go wrong with the MSI GE63.

Laura Johnston

MSI GS65 Stealth Thin

If you can afford the price tag, it is well worth the money. It out performs any other laptop I have tried for gaming, and the transportable design and incredible display also make it ideal for work.

Andrew Teoh

Brother MFC-L9570CDW Multifunction Printer

Touch screen visibility and operation was great and easy to navigate. Each menu and sub-menu was in an understandable order and category

Louise Coady

Brother MFC-L9570CDW Multifunction Printer

The printer was convenient, produced clear and vibrant images and was very easy to use

Edwina Hargreaves

WD My Cloud Home

I would recommend this device for families and small businesses who want one safe place to store all their important digital content and a way to easily share it with friends, family, business partners, or customers.

Featured Content

Product Launch Showcase

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?