Typo in expert report lead to spat between Samsung, Apple

An Australian Federal Court judge advised Samsung's attorney to reconsider allegations she made against Apple

A Federal Court judge warned Samsung on Wednesday to rethink its allegation that Apple improperly influenced expert witnesses key to the companies' ongoing patent infringement trial.

Justice Annabelle Claire Bennett advised Samsung counsel Katrina Howard that she made a "serious statement" on Monday directed toward Apple, and that she might want to consider professionally "what you want to do with that."

"I'll leave it at that," Bennett said.

Howard charged that it was "most inappropriate" for Apple to call a meeting to discuss a change to a joint report written by three experts weighing in on whether Apple infringes on three of Samsung's 3G patents in its iPhone 4, 4S models and second iPad.

One of the experts, Aruna Seneviratne of the University of New South Wales, testified on Wednesday that Apple did not pressure him to change the report during a meeting with the company's hired law firm, Freehills.

Apple lawyers pointed out what appeared to be a typographical error in the report, Seneviratne said. The report was amended, and Apple notified Samsung late Sunday night.

Howard pointed to an email written by Seneviratne that hinted Apple had pushed him to reconsider. Seneviratne said the email was merely his own wording regarding the change, and that it was not indicative of pressure from Apple.

"It's the way I wrote that email," Seneviratne said.

Stephen Burley, representing Apple, said it was unacceptable that Howard made an accusation on such a "flimsy basis."

The kerfuffle kicked off a session called the "hot tub" in which Seneviratne and two other technical experts, Riaz Esmailzadeh and Rami Mukhtar , answered questions at the same time from attorneys. In Australian court, the hot tub arrangement is believed to offer greater clarity on the technical issues since experts can interact with one another.

The three experts filed a joint report outlining their interpretation of Samsung's 3G patents. During questioning, Seneviratne and Mukhtar disagreed over the technical implementation of the so-called "512" patent, one of three patents Samsung accuses Apple of violating.

The patent is titled "Method and apparatus for data transmission in a mobile telecommunication system supporting enhanced uplink service" and deals with how a device adjusts transmitting power depending on a device's distance from a base station.

Apple contends it follows UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunications System) standards in its devices, and Samsung's 3G patents are incorporated into some of those standards. Apple maintains, however, there are variations in which those standards can be implemented which do not infringe on the Korean company's patents.

But Apple also says it doesn't know exactly the implementation of the standards in its baseband chips, which are made by Qualcomm and Intel. Samsung is working to obtain the source code from those manufacturers to see how those chips function to try and prove its infringement case.

Apple's infringement allegations will be dealt with later in the trial. Apple filed suit against Samsung in Australia in July 2011, alleging that the company's Galaxy tablet infringed on patents it holds related to touchscreen technology.

Send news tips and comments to jeremy_kirk@idg.com

Join the newsletter!

Or

Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Keep up with the latest tech news, reviews and previews by subscribing to the Good Gear Guide newsletter.

Jeremy Kirk

IDG News Service
Show Comments

Most Popular Reviews

Latest Articles

Resources

PCW Evaluation Team

Tom Pope

Dynabook Portégé X30L-G

Ultimately this laptop has achieved everything I would hope for in a laptop for work, while fitting that into a form factor and weight that is remarkable.

Tom Sellers

MSI P65

This smart laptop was enjoyable to use and great to work on – creating content was super simple.

Lolita Wang

MSI GT76

It really doesn’t get more “gaming laptop” than this.

Jack Jeffries

MSI GS75

As the Maserati or BMW of laptops, it would fit perfectly in the hands of a professional needing firepower under the hood, sophistication and class on the surface, and gaming prowess (sports mode if you will) in between.

Taylor Carr

MSI PS63

The MSI PS63 is an amazing laptop and I would definitely consider buying one in the future.

Christopher Low

Brother RJ-4230B

This small mobile printer is exactly what I need for invoicing and other jobs such as sending fellow tradesman details or step-by-step instructions that I can easily print off from my phone or the Web.

Featured Content

Product Launch Showcase

Don’t have an account? Sign up here

Don't have an account? Sign up now

Forgot password?